West Memphis Three denied new trial, even though new DNA evidence proves innocence![views:6007][posts:12]_________________________________ [Sep 11,2008 12:31pm - samYam ""] From The Associated Press A judge on Wednesday rejected claims that DNA evidence clears three men convicted of killing three 8-year-old boys in 1993 and denied their requests for a new trial. Lawyers for Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley — known to supporters as the “West Memphis Three” — had argued that new DNA tests would prove their clients’ innocence. Both Baldwin and Misskelley claimed their lawyers failed to adequately represent them during trial. Their lawyers said DNA evidence provided by Echols’ defense team showed that the men did not kill Steven Branch, Christopher Byers and Michael Moore. “The court finds that (Echols’s) DNA-testing results are inconclusive because they do not raise a reasonable probability that he did not commit the offenses; that is, they are inconclusive as to his claim of actual innocence,” Circuit Court Judge David wrote in a 10-page order denying the men’s requests for a new trial. In his appeal, Echols argued that newly analyzed DNA found no trace of the defendants at the crime scene. But Burnett said he agreed with prosecutors that the absence of DNA didn’t equal innocence. “Proof of actual innocence requires more than his exclusion as the source of a handful of biological material that is not dispositive of the identity of a killer,” the judge wrote. Burnett also said that even if he agreed that the new DNA evidence should be heard in court, he would still deny Echols’ request for a new trial because there was “not compelling evidence that he would be acquitted.” Police found the three boys’ bodies in a drainage ditch a day after their May 5, 1993, disappearance from West Memphis. A month passed before police arrested the three defendants, who were teens at the time. Misskelley told investigators he watched Baldwin and Echols sexually assault and beat two of the boys as he ran down another trying to escape. A jury sentenced Misskelley to life in prison plus 40 years. Baldwin got life without parole and Echols was sentenced to die. The Arkansas Supreme Court has upheld their convictions. |
| _______________________________ [Sep 11,2008 12:37pm - Yeti ""] samYam said:“Proof of actual innocence requires more than his exclusion as the source of a handful of biological material that is not dispositive of the identity of a killer,” the judge wrote. uh, what? i'd call DNA pretty solid evidence. |
| ________________________________ [Sep 11,2008 12:48pm - Pires ""] that sucks. only one court left to go to, and its never guaranteed that you'll even come close to there. |
| _________________________________ [Sep 11,2008 12:48pm - samYam ""] no kidding, can't get more solid evidence than DNA. |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:03pm - AndrewBastard ""] I just started following this case... watching Paradise Lost and Paradise Lost II on youtube a few nights ago. crazy shit. To be honest, part of me thinks they did it. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:13pm - demondave ""] Yeti said: samYam said:�Proof of actual innocence requires more than his exclusion as the source of a handful of biological material that is not dispositive of the identity of a killer,� the judge wrote. uh, what? i'd call DNA pretty solid evidence. I don't know the full case, but from what was posted above it seems that there is not DNA evidence. It sounds like they are saying that since there is no DNA evidence tying them directly, they can not be held as guilty. |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:24pm - Conservationist ""] AndrewBastard said:To be honest, part of me thinks they did it. And Mumia, and OJ. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:28pm - Paul CNV ""] I was just reading about this yesterday .... I've seen both movies and read the book. The shit kicker stepfather that looks like he has a steel plate in his head is the one that did it... |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:34pm - Paul CNV ""] [img] |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 12:39pm - Paul CNV ""] This sap... He has a lengthy criminal record/former drug addict and married a heroin addict... Arkansas needs it's scapegoats... The place is about as fucked up as Salem Mass in the Puritan days |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 1:19pm - Conservationist ""] I hope they execute the WM3 just to get people over their pity. We don't need more Jesuses. |
| _______________________________________ [Mar 6,2010 2:06pm - AndrewBastard ""] That crazy dude supports the WM3 now! He passed a lie detector test and shit...I thought he did it for a long time too. |